just a couple things i thought was different
3 posters
Mr. Harts Creative Writing :: Old Man and the Sea :: Old Man and the Sea [Random Observations Pages 0-32]
Page 1 of 1
just a couple things i thought was different
I do not know why but I felt like when the boy and the old man had the beers the second time when they actually had dinner, i couldn't help but think it represented something. Also i looked past the fact of them talking about baseball, but they kept talking about it so maybe it can be associated with the new top writers in America or something? I don't know just something i thought was weird
Steve W.- Posts : 6
Join date : 2012-11-27
About the baseball thing...
On page 17: The old man says
I thought the Yankees represented Hemingway's writing career. The first quote could translate into "My writing is not done." (lose=done for)
The second quote could be Hemingway telling his fans to still have faith in his writing, that his writing is still great.
DiMaggio could represent Hemingway. Rephrasing the quote into "Think of the great Hemingway, he could do anything"
Does that make sense?
"The Yankees cannot lose."
"Have faith in the Yankees my son. Think of the great DiMaggio"
I thought the Yankees represented Hemingway's writing career. The first quote could translate into "My writing is not done." (lose=done for)
The second quote could be Hemingway telling his fans to still have faith in his writing, that his writing is still great.
DiMaggio could represent Hemingway. Rephrasing the quote into "Think of the great Hemingway, he could do anything"
Does that make sense?
VivianH- Posts : 29
Join date : 2012-11-28
Why baseball?
I also noticed how the old man and boy kept talking about baseball. I don't understand why though... it just seemed like every time the old man would try and talk about something else, the boy would redirect the conversation right back to baseball and insist that that be the topic of discussion. It's almost as if he wanted to keep the old man distracted from other thoughts.
Kayla I.- Posts : 33
Join date : 2012-11-28
Age : 29
Why baseball?
May be baseball is meant to represent one's determination and skill?Kayla I. wrote:I also noticed how the old man and boy kept talking about baseball. I don't understand why though... it just seemed like every time the old man would try and talk about something else, the boy would redirect the conversation right back to baseball and insist that that be the topic of discussion. It's almost as if he wanted to keep the old man distracted from other thoughts.
I know that Hemingway could have chosen any sport, but he chose baseball specifically. It could to be due to the fact that a batter has 3 chances before he is out. (unlike any other sport)
The boy keeps reminding the old man about the game, which could translate in him saying "You're still in the game. Remember you have a limited amount of times at bat. Keep your eye on the ball" This could be Hemingway's fans saying "Don't lose focus on you writing. You're still in the game."
I know it might be a bit far fetched...
VivianH- Posts : 29
Join date : 2012-11-28
Similar topics
» Eating- pg 27
» the sail of the old man's boat and it's a pain that the title has to be more than 10 characters
» Such a Random Thought
» so not realy an observation but a thought
» the sail of the old man's boat and it's a pain that the title has to be more than 10 characters
» Such a Random Thought
» so not realy an observation but a thought
Mr. Harts Creative Writing :: Old Man and the Sea :: Old Man and the Sea [Random Observations Pages 0-32]
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|